Nostalgia is a cruel blockhead at Christmas

The Annual Charlie Brown Ritual: Reflecting on Tradition and Change..

Every year, many of us partake in the timeless ritual of watching A Charlie Brown Christmas. That animated classic, with its melancholy tone, manages to evoke a sense of nostalgia that feels almost bittersweet.

For decades, people have wondered: what makes this special so enduring? After all, Charlie Brown is often consumed by negativity, struggling to find joy in the Christmas season. It takes Linus dropping his security blanket and delivering a heartfelt monologue about the true meaning of Christmas to momentarily lift Charlie’s spirits. By the end, he’s singing Hark! The Herald Angels Sing with everyone else—but is that truly the resolution?

At its surface, it’s the story of a clumsy kid who’s constantly called a “blockhead” by the very people who are supposed to be his friends. Yet there’s something deeper at play—something that continues to resonate year after year.

x x x

As we grow older, life inevitably changes. Some of you reading this have already felt the sting of those changes: the loss of parents, family members, or friends who were central to your celebrations. Others might not yet have experienced these shifts but will in time.

What often remains constant is the commercialization of Christmas. It taps into our nostalgia, using those warm, familiar memories to encourage us to buy, create, and relive moments that we hope will endure. Coke mastered it..

Yet even commercialization can’t prevent the inevitable: the traditions we hold dear often fade, morph, or disappear altogether. For good sometimes.

For me, A Charlie Brown Christmas endures because it reflects this truth. While the special itself remains unchanged, the way we experience it shifts. The memories it evokes, the people we watch it with, and the traditions surrounding it all evolve.

The reality is, many of the things we cherish about Christmas are fleeting. Traditions we upheld years ago may no longer be possible. Perhaps your family dinner has grown smaller, or the specific dishes you once enjoyed have been replaced. Maybe those once-sacred outings—like Christmas bowling or movie nights—are no longer feasible because those businesses decided not to be open or have shut down altogether..

And then there are the deeply personal losses: parents who once cleaned up the wrapping paper, friends and relatives who were staples of your holiday gatherings but are no longer around. These changes can leave us feeling desolate.. longing for a past that can’t be reclaimed no matter what actions we take.

Even large, tight-knit families that manage to maintain traditions will eventually face change, because change is inevitable. And that inevitability is at the heart of Charlie Brown’s melancholy.

Charlie Brown’s struggle isn’t just about the commercialism of Christmas. It’s about his inability to accept change. He’s searching for something constant, a tradition untouched by time. But as life shifts and evolves, he feels that the magic of the season is slipping away.

The friends who call him a blockhead haven’t yet experienced the losses that he feels so deeply. But one day, they will. Change will touch their lives, too, and they’ll find themselves longing for something they can no longer have.

So, this Christmas, enjoy what you have. Embrace the traditions you partake in this year, knowing that they may not endure. Families come and go. Friends come and go. Traditions come and go. But the moments you create right now are real, and they matter.

This is advice I’m trying to take myself. With both my parents gone and the weight of traumatic events over the past five years, my traditions have changed dramatically. It’s challenging to create new ones for my child while my mind drifts back to the past.

But if Charlie Brown could find joy, even briefly, so can we. Live in the moment. That’s where the magic of Christmas truly lies.

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK